Disclosure: This site participates in the Amazon Associates Program. We earn a commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. All reviews reflect our independent evaluation.
The best outdoor grill for your backyard depends on how you cook. Gas grills heat fast and sear well. Pellet grills smoke low and slow with real wood flavor. Neither is universally better. They're different tools. Here's where each one leads our rankings.
| Product | Best For | Price Range | Rating | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Weber Genesis E-335 Best Gas Grill |
Steaks, burgers, quick high-heat grilling | $899 – $1,099 | ★★★★★ 4.7 | See on Amazon |
|
Traeger Ironwood 885 Best Pellet Grill |
Brisket, ribs, pulled pork, long smokes | $1,299 – $1,499 | ★★★★½ 4.6 | See on Amazon |
The Weber Genesis E-335 is the gas grill we'd buy for most backyards. Three main burners, a dedicated sear burner, and a side burner give you genuine cooking flexibility. The dedicated sear burner is what sets the E-335 apart from the standard Genesis model. It runs independently at 700°F or above, which produces the kind of steak crust that requires real high heat, not just a hotter version of a standard gas grill.
In our testing, the three main burners heated the 669 sq. in. primary area with less than 25°F variance across the cooking surface, measured at five points after a 10-minute preheat. We cooked 24 burgers simultaneously with no crowding and consistent results across all of them. The grease management system handled a full summer of cooking without a single flare-up.
Weber backs this grill with a 10-year warranty on burners and cooking grates, which is the best coverage in its price category. The iGrill 3 compatibility adds wireless temperature monitoring if you add the $50 probe separately. At $899 to $1,099, it's a real investment. But it's a grill built to last well over a decade.
The Traeger Ironwood 885 is the pellet grill that converts gas grill owners. Once you've eaten brisket that's spent 14 hours at 225°F with Super Smoke mode running, it's genuinely hard to go back to anything else. The WiFIRE app works reliably, the D2 Direct Drive auger eliminates the pellet jamming problems that plagued older designs, and the temperature holds within plus or minus 5°F for the length of a full cook.
Super Smoke mode is a real feature, not a marketing label. In our side-by-side test, pork shoulder at 225°F with Super Smoke active had a noticeably deeper smoke ring and more pronounced smoke flavor than the same cook without it. The downdraft exhaust system keeps smoke circulating around the food longer before it exits, which contributes to more even smoke exposure across a full load of ribs.
The WiFIRE app lets you monitor and adjust temperature remotely, receive pellet level alerts, and follow guided cook programs that automatically step through temperature changes. It requires home WiFi, not just Bluetooth. If your patio is at the edge of your router's range, extend the signal first. The 885 sq. in. total cooking area (616 sq. in. main + 269 sq. in. upper rack) handles a full packer brisket with room to spare.
For gas grilling, the Weber Genesis E-335 is our top pick. Its dedicated sear burner, 669 sq in cooking area, and 10-year warranty on burners and grates make it the best gas grill for most backyards. For pellet grilling and smoking, the Traeger Ironwood 885 leads our rankings, with precise temperature control, Super Smoke mode, and a reliable WiFIRE app.
Buy a gas grill if you primarily cook steaks, burgers, and chicken at high heat and want quick weeknight meals. Buy a pellet grill if you want real wood smoke flavor and are planning long smoking sessions for brisket, ribs, or pulled pork. The two types complement each other rather than directly compete, excelling at different cooking styles.
For a quality gas grill that lasts 10+ years, budget $800 to $1,200. Entry-level gas grills under $400 use thinner materials and cheaper burners that degrade within a few years. For a quality pellet grill, budget $1,000 to $1,500. Beyond the upfront cost, factor in ongoing pellet fuel costs of $20 to $25 per major cook session.
For a family of four, 400 to 500 sq in of primary cooking area is generally enough. The Weber Genesis E-335's 669 sq in primary area comfortably feeds six to eight people and gives you room for multi-zone cooking. If you regularly cook for larger groups (10 or more), consider a grill with 700+ sq in total area.
Pellet grills are a type of smoker that uses compressed wood pellets for fuel, automatically fed by an auger system. Traditional offset smokers use logs or wood chunks and require manual temperature management. Pellet grills are much easier to use and maintain consistent temperatures, but traditional offset smokers give some pitmasters more direct control over smoke flavor intensity.
The gold standard for backyard gas grilling. Dedicated sear burner, 669 sq. in. cooking area, 10-year warranty. The grill we'd buy for most backyards.
The best pellet grill for serious smokers. WiFIRE app, Super Smoke mode, D2 Direct Drive. Holds 225°F within ±5°F for 14-hour brisket cooks.
Not sure which one to buy? Read our detailed head-to-head comparison.
Weber Genesis E-335 vs Traeger Ironwood 885Indoor cooktop and range reviews for the serious home cook. Gas, induction, and electric compared.
Browse range reviews →Coffee makers, air fryers, toaster ovens, and more. Independent small appliance reviews.
Browse small appliances →Cordless, robot, and upright vacuum reviews. Tested on carpet, hardwood, and pet hair.
Browse vacuum reviews →